Terra Classic Audit Proposal Returns With New Pay Per Job Payment Structure
Terra Classic’s proposed independent security audit by SolidProof is back with a revised payment structure after the previous proposal failed to gain approval. This time, the proposal introduces a Pay Per Job system, allowing the community to approve the audit work first, while payments are handled through separate Community Pool spending proposals.
The revised proposal aims to address concerns surrounding the previous payment arrangement, which required the audit fee to be paid entirely upfront. Instead, the new structure divides the payment into two stages, with 40% paid before the audit begins and the remaining 60% paid when SolidProof delivers its findings.
The proposed audit carries a fixed fee of $85,200 for 568 engineer hours. It will cover Terra Classic’s live core blockchain code, as well as several important developments being prepared for the upcoming network upgrade.
A New Payment Structure After the Previous Proposal Failed
The previous SolidProof audit proposal, Proposal 12228, did not pass after concerns were raised about its payment conditions, particularly the requirement to pay the audit fee upfront.
The revised proposal introduces a different approach. Rather than requesting the entire amount through one spending proposal, the Pay Per Job system separates approval of the work from the release of funds.
Under this arrangement, the community first votes on whether to approve the audit itself. If the text proposal passes, two additional Community Pool spending proposals will be submitted separately.
The proposed payment schedule is:
| Payment Stage | Percentage | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Before the audit begins | 40% | $34,080 |
| Upon delivery of audit findings | 60% | $51,120 |
| Total | 100% | $85,200 |
The second payment also covers the full re-audit after developers complete the required fixes. There is no additional charge for this re-audit.
Importantly, the current text proposal does not request a specific amount of LUNC. Each payment will have its own spending proposal, with the required LUNC calculated according to the market rate at the time of submission.
What Will SolidProof Audit?
The proposed audit covers the Terra Classic Core repository at a frozen commit dated October 15, 2026.
The audit target includes Terra Classic Core v4.1.1, which is already live on mainnet following Proposal 12233, alongside additional developments prepared on the ustc_staking branch.
The expanded scope is particularly important because it includes several major components planned for future network development.
The main audit areas include:
1. Terra Classic Core Protocol
SolidProof will examine the core blockchain implementation, including monetary and fee mechanisms, treasury functions, tax distribution, tax exemptions, oracle systems, market functions, dynamic commissions, vesting, application wiring and CosmWasm integrations.
2. Market Module 2.0
The audit will examine the reimplementation of Market Module 2.0 and its reactivated swap economics. This component is important for the network’s market functionality and future development.
3. USTC Staking Module
The new x/ustcstaking module will undergo security reviews covering its staking and reward mechanisms. This is an important addition as Terra Classic continues working on new USTC-related utility.
4. Tax Redirect Mechanism
SolidProof will review the tax redirect mechanism and market accumulator account within the network’s fee and burn tax processing system.
5. V15 Upgrade Handler
The audit will also examine the v15 upgrade handler, alongside oracle TWAP and freshness mechanisms, to identify potential security and implementation issues before deployment.
The audit will cover approximately 30,329 raw lines of code, including 23,203 non-test and non-generated Go lines, together with 31 Protocol Buffer definitions.
However, the agreement also establishes specific exclusions. These include upstream dependencies that have not been modified by Terra Classic, deployed CosmWasm contracts, validator infrastructure, relayers, RPC providers and formal verification.
This means the audit focuses on Terra Classic’s own implementation and its integration with underlying blockchain technologies rather than independently auditing every external component.
Audit Costs $85,200, While Developers Commit to Free Remediation
According to the proposal, SolidProof will charge $150 per engineer hour, with a total of 568 hours allocated across five workstreams.
The cost breakdown is:
| Audit Workstream | Engineer Hours | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Core protocol audit | 288 | $43,200 |
| Framework migration and state integrity | 88 | $13,200 |
| Adversarial simulation and economic review | 64 | $9,600 |
| Market Module 2.0, USTC staking and v15 upgrade | 96 | $14,400 |
| Full re-audit after remediation | 32 | $4,800 |
| Total | 568 | $85,200 |
One important aspect of the revised proposal is that the developers responsible for fixing identified vulnerabilities will not charge the Community Pool for their work.
Renzo from LunaClassicDAO and Till, also known as Frag from Bumeo Capital, will work together to address the findings reported by SolidProof.
The community will therefore fund the independent security audit and associated conversion costs, while the remediation work will be provided at no additional cost.
This arrangement removes the separate $20,000 remediation budget included in the previous proposal.
How Will the Community Pool Funds Be Managed?
Although the audit fee is fixed at $85,200 in US dollars, the payments will originate from the Terra Classic Community Pool in LUNC.
The proposed process involves transferring LUNC from the Community Pool to a receiving multisig wallet, converting the funds into USDC through SimpleSwap, and then sending the USDC to SolidProof.
The proposal estimates that SimpleSwap conversion costs could range between 2% and 3.5% for each payment tranche based on recent quotes.
Additionally, Terra Classic’s 1.5% transaction tax may apply to each on-chain LUNC transfer, depending on the transfer route. The proposal accounts for up to two taxed transfers.
Taking these expenses into consideration, the total amount required could reach approximately $91,000 under the estimated worst-case scenario, or around 7% above the contracted audit fee.
Each spending proposal will be calculated using a live conversion quote to ensure SolidProof receives the agreed USDC amount.
Any remaining LUNC or USDC after payment will be returned to the Community Pool. Any unearned portion of the upfront payment will also be refunded according to the agreement.
The receiving multisig will have four signers: Renzo, Frag, Puya and Classic DAO. The multisig address, signing threshold and SolidProof payment address will be published in the respective spending proposals.
What Happens After the Proposal Passes?
The proposed timeline establishes several stages, beginning with the approval of the text proposal and the first payment.
SolidProof will only begin work after the first spending proposal passes and the upfront payment is received. The agreement provides for a three-week lead time after payment, subject to the auditor’s availability.
The expected schedule is:
| Timeline | Expected Milestone |
|---|---|
| After text proposal approval | First spending proposal for $34,080 |
| After first payment | Three-week lead time before work begins |
| End of Week 1 | Threat Model and Architecture Note |
| End of Week 5 | Interim Findings Report |
| End of Week 8 | Audit Findings and Draft Audit Report |
| After findings delivery | Second spending proposal for $51,120 |
| Within four weeks | Developers complete remediation |
| Within one week after remediation | Re-audit and fix verification |
| Within five business days after re-audit | Final Audit Report |
SolidProof has also committed to reporting critical security findings within 24 hours and high severity findings within three business days.
Critical and high severity findings will remain confidential until a patch has been released and validator adoption confirmed, or until 90 days have passed from the report, whichever occurs earlier.
The final audit report and remediation status are expected to be published for the community through Agora.
How Is the New Proposal Different From Proposal 12228?
The revised proposal introduces several changes beyond its payment structure. It also expands the audit scope to include Market Module 2.0, USTC staking and the v15 upgrade handler.
The main differences are:
| Category | Previous Proposal 12228 | New Proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Auditor | SolidProof | SolidProof |
| Approval process | Spending proposal first | Text vote first |
| Payment | 100% upfront | 40% upfront, 60% on findings delivery |
| Audit fee | $70,800 | $85,200 |
| Engineer hours | 472 hours | 568 hours |
| Additional buffer | 20% buffer | No buffer |
| Remediation budget | $20,000 | $0 |
| Remediation team | OrbitLabs | Renzo and Till (Frag) |
| Audit scope | Earlier core codebase | Core codebase plus Market Module 2.0, USTC staking and v15 |
| Payment structure | One spending proposal | Two separate spending proposals |
While the new proposal has a higher audit fee, the expanded scope includes additional components that were not part of the previous agreement.
It also eliminates the separate remediation budget and introduces a payment structure that requires additional community approval before each payment is released.
Why Does an Independent Security Audit Matter for Terra Classic?
Terra Classic continues developing its blockchain infrastructure, introducing new modules and improving existing network functionality.
However, adding new features also increases the importance of identifying potential security vulnerabilities before those developments become active on mainnet.
The proposed audit aims to provide validators, developers and holders with an independent assessment of the network’s core implementation and upcoming additions.
This is particularly relevant for Market Module 2.0 and USTC staking, which involve financial mechanisms and the movement or distribution of funds.
An independent review can help identify weaknesses, provide developers with actionable findings and improve transparency around the security of future upgrades.
The revised proposal also gives the community greater control over the funding process by separating approval of the audit from the two payment stages.
Ultimately, the proposal represents another step in Terra Classic’s ongoing infrastructure development. Whether it moves forward will depend on the community’s decision through governance.
